https://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/reviews/books/0-316-30404-2.html
Review: The Last Soul Among Wolves, by Melissa Caruso
| Series: |
The Echo Archives #2 |
| Publisher: |
Orbit |
| Copyright: |
August 2025 |
| ISBN: |
0-316-30404-2 |
| Format: |
Kindle |
| Pages: |
355 |
The Last Soul Among Wolves is urban high fantasy with strong
mystery vibes. It is a direct sequel to The Last Hour Between Worlds. You need the previous book for some
character setup (and this book would spoil it badly), but you don't have
to remember the first book in detail. Only the main plot outcomes are
directly relevant and the characters will remind you of those.
Kembrel Thorne is a Hound, the equivalent of a police detective in the
medieval-inspired city setting of this series, but this book does not open
with an official assignment. Instead, she has been dragged by her
childhood friend Jaycel Morningrey as company for a reading of the will of
old lady Lovegrace, reclusive owner of a gothic mansion on an island
connected to the city by an intermittent sandbar. A surprise reunion with
her gang of childhood friends ensues, followed by the revelation that they
are all in serious trouble.
Shortly after Kem left the group to become a Hound, the remaining four,
plus several other apparently random people, got entangled with a powerful
Echo artifact. Now that Lovegrace has died, one of them will inherit the
artifact and the ability to make a wish, but only one. The rest will be
killed at decreasing intervals until only the winner is left alive.
The Last Hour Between Worlds was fae fantasy built around a problem
that was more of a puzzle than a mystery. The Last Soul Among
Wolves is closer to a classic mystery: A cast of characters are brought
together and semi-isolated in a rural house, they start dying, and it's up
to the detective to solve the mystery of their death before it's too late.
In this case, the initial mechanism of death is supernatural and not in
doubt — the challenge instead is how to stop it from happening again — but
Kem's problems quickly become more complicated.
As mystery plots go, this is more thriller than classical despite the
setting. There are a few scenes of analyzing clues, but Kem is more likely
to use the time-honored protagonist technique of throwing herself into
danger and learning what's going on via the villain monologues. As readers
of the previous book would expect, Rika Nonesuch is here too, hired by
another of Kem's old friends, and the two navigate their personal feelings
and the rivalry between their guilds in much the way that they did in
the Last Hour Between Worlds. As in the first book, there is a
sapphic romance subplot, but it's a very slow burn asexual romance.
The best part of this series continues to be the world-building. The
previous book introduced the idea of the Echoes and sent the characters
exploring into stranger and stranger depths. This book fleshes out the
rules in more detail, creating something that feels partly like a fae
realm and partly like high fantasy involving gods, but diverges from both
into a logic of its own. The ending satisfyingly passes my test of fantasy
mysteries: Resolving the mystery requires understanding and applying the
rules of the setting, which are sufficiently strange to create interesting
outcomes but coherent enough that the reader doesn't feel like the author
is cheating.
There are some hissable villains here, but my favorite part of this book
was the way Caruso added a lot of nuance and poignancy to the Echoes
rather than showing them only as an uncanny threat. That choice made the
world feel deeper and richer. It's not yet clear whether that element is
setup for a longer-term series plot, but I hope Caruso will develop the
story in that direction.
It felt to me like Caruso is aiming for an ongoing series rather than a
multi-volume story with a definite ending. She avoids a full episodic
reset — Rika, in particular, gets considerable character development and
new complications that bode well for future volumes — but it doesn't feel
like the series is building towards an imminent climax. This is not a
complaint. I enjoy these characters and this world and will happily keep
devouring each new series entry.
If you liked The Last Hour Between Worlds, I think you will like
this. It doesn't have the same delight of initial discovery of the great
world-building, but the plot is satisfying and a bit more complex and the
supporting characters are even better than those in the first book. Once
again, Caruso kept me turning the pages, and I'm now looking forward to a
third volume. Recommended.
The third book in the series has not yet been announced, but there are
indications on social media that it is coming.
Rating: 7 out of 10
https://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/reviews/books/0-316-30404-2.html